What happened to mountain slopes during Helene? Geologists are gathering information to prepare for the next storm

The Toodies Creek debris flow in Yancey County tragically claimed the lives of residents living along the small stream which the debris flow followed.

In the nine months since Helene’s arrival in western North Carolina, geologists have worked steadily to better understand how to reduce future landslide-related impacts on life and property. While landslide themselves cannot be prevented from happening under extreme precipitation conditions, decision making during, and particularly before, a storm can save lives and reduce damage to infrastructure and personal property. Understanding what made certain landslides more damaging than others requires both extensive fieldwork and study of remote sensing data, like lidar imagery. ALC Principal Geologist Jennifer Bauer and Project Geologist Philip Prince recently presented some of the findings of their post-Helene work in US Geological Survey seminars. Video recordings of the talks are linked below. If you have ever wondered what a geologist sees in one of Helene’s thousands of landslide scars, these videos will give a glance of how we do our work day-to-day.

Jennifer Bauer

Jennifer’s talk focuses on the use of landslide mapping and modeling to understand and (more importantly) communicate landslide hazard before storms hit. Understanding landslide potential in a given landscape requires that geologists understand the landslide history of a landscape. Landslide inventories involving both lidar imagery analysis and lots of boots-on-the-ground fieldwork help geologists learn what has happened in the past.

Helene certainly was not the first landslide-producing storm in the western North Carolina Blue Ridge. Geologists study lidar imagery (left) and field-verify observations to determine where past slope failures occurred. This information illustrates the type of topography that may produce future slide events.

Once the geologic details that can produce landslides are understood (slope shape, slope steepness, soil type, etc.), models of potential landslide hazard zones can be developed. As Jennifer’s talk shows, the overwhelming majority of Helene’s landslides came from mapped hazard areas, but not every hazard area produced a landslide…this time. Hazard mapping can show mountain residents areas that are potentially dangerous is storms (don’t worry; it’s not everywhere-not even close) and help with decision making regarding where to live and how to prepare for the next big event.

Improving understanding of where debris flows will go as they move downslope–and how wide they may be–will be a focal point of landslide research in coming years. The teal color shows existing modeling of a debris flow path; the yellow outline shows the actual extent of the affected area.

Philip Prince

Philip’s talk is centered around the geologic details of Helene’s debris flow landslides. Debris flows are fast-moving, fluidized landslides that can travel long distances very quickly. Often called “mudslides,” debris flows actually carry huge amounts of rock and boulder debris and tremendous numbers of trees, so a debris flow impact is much more damaging than what might result from mud alone.

A debris flow conceptual model (top) attempts to illustrate the thin soil “birthplace” of many western North Carolina debris flows. Starting as small landslides which fluidize due to soil saturation, debris flows pick up more and more material moving downslope. The lower photography shows what a debris flow starting point (initiation zone) looks like in the field. Note the smooth bedrock surface exposed by the initial slide.

Philip illustrates where debris flows start in the landscape and how they accumulate so much material on their path downslope. A large debris flow could cover a football field with a few feet of mud, rocks and trees, but even small debris flows are surprisingly destructive. By understanding what type of geologic materials and slope settings produced debris flows during Helene, we can better understand what areas may be hazardous in the next event. Planners can also what parts of the landscape may be more susceptible to landslides when disturbed for building, as well as what areas at the foot of the mountains might be reached by debris flows.

This soil consisting of stacked, shingled rock fragments doesn’t look like much, but it is actually the material which slid to initiate one of the deadly Craigtown debris flows in Fairview, North Carolina. Understanding the distribution and behavior of soils like this is critical to improving understanding of potential debris flow behavior.